I had a 99% blogging failure rate – here’s what I did

Donald Rumsfeld at Town Hall Meeting

Recently I told you that one of a few big breaks for me was when two “frolic” articles ranked high up in MIGHTY Google.

Rather than repeat myself, you can read about that here.

I didn’t tell the whole story.

For all you know, those two articles, which paved the way to growing a huge site, were two out of twelve published articles.

That would be an amazing result, right?

Sadly, those articles weren’t the 11th and 12th published on the site.

It was something like articles number 199 and 200. The exact number I forget, but I do know I had published a ton of content until I struck gold.

That’s a 99% failure rate.

OUCH, right?

I wrote all of that content preceding 2 successful articles on blind faith. I kept writing long after those two articles were a success. Outsourcing came later.

While those two articles were a success, they didn’t make millions. They were a success relative to everything else on the site; a marked improvement. Lucky for me I recognized their potential.

I piggybacked on the modest success of those two articles.

After that, everything fell into place. I replicated the concept behind those articles. Things grew from there.

Current failure rate: 80%

Over time I dramatically reduced the failure rate to 80%. I crunched numbers a few months ago and discovered 1 in 5 of my published articles are a financial success.

Put another way, I’m batting a 20% success rate with content.

Sounds bad, doesn’t it?

It’s not. That 20% of articles make a lot of money.

Moreover, another good chunk breakeven so it’s not all doom and gloom.

And then a big chunk lose money.

That’s the nature of this business. It makes it tricky but also an absolute hoot. The big wins are thrilling.

I tell you this because I don’t want it to make this stuff sound like it’s easier than it is.

At the same time, once you see results, if you replicate what works, growth can speed up fast.

Many other factors at play

As your traffic and content volume grows, so too do inbound links which fuels more growth.

Your site authority in Google search grows.

Google’s frown upon your site turns upside down. Frown… smirk… smile and if lucky, a big fat guffaw of favoritism shovelling traffic your way.

Then it’s rinse and repeat. Turn on the cruise control and ride into the sunset.

Watch out for speed bumps

Your site is cruising along at a nice clip, you’re loving life when one day you log into Analytics and ad accounts and see a sudden drop.

Heart rate quickens.

Sweat beads form.

Sounds like I know from personal experience, doesn’t it? Yes, I do on more than one occasion.

What on Earth happened, you ask yourself?

You frantically start analyzing.

You search “Any Google update today?”

There’s no Google update. You’re not sure that’s good or bad at this point. Probably good.

What the heck?

Down 10% in one day. You can stomach a 10% haircut, but what if it doesn’t stop there?

You make it through the day exhausted. Sleep. Wake up and go straight to Analytics.

Boo-ya… site traffic is restored.


It was a blip.

Here’s a heads up.

Blips will happen.

Worse things will happen at some point (likely).

Be prepared.

I once had my biggest site deindexed from Google for a malware attack. That was a rough 3 to 4 weeks until I got the issue fixed and reindexed with the BIG G.

How do you prepare?

Save up a LIQUID nest egg as fast as you can. By liquid, I mean an ability to access cash fairly quickly.

Diversify revenue sources if you can.

Risk abounds

This line of work is risky.

But so too is working a job.

People get fired and laid off from jobs all the time.

It’s a cruel world.

I once had a professor who had tenure who told us we needed to save “NO” money. “NO” money is when you have the financial security to do what you please.

He was a business prof and knew about investing etc. He said he had 17 years of “NO” money saved up and invested which meant he could go 17 years without a paycheck.

“NO” money gave him control over his life. He could refuse his employer and rest easy. I doubt he ever had to quit his job or refuse his employer because being a tenured prof is a great gig. Nevertheless, he slept soundly knowing he could.

“NO” money for us refers to “NO” way that I’m getting a job; “NO job” for short.

Can I get my article failure rate down to 50% or lower?

Maybe. I think the key to doing that is continuing investment into improving existing content (which I’m doing).

If I stopped publishing new content and only worked on existing content, I think I could get 50% or more of the content profitable.

But I’m not doing that.

I’m at a stage where I’m kinda pivoting yet again from a pure traffic focus to building a brand.

Building a brand hemorrhages money in the short run.

I continue to invest money into content, some of which is intended not to get search traffic but instead elevate the website.

Will it work?

I don’t know.

It could be another spectacular failure.

At some point I may pull the plug on new content, roll up my sleeves and endeavor to make every article profitable. That would be quite a feat. I’d also save a lot of money. I’ve certainly considered this approach.

From a search traffic perspective, I suspect if I elevated every article, the entire site would benefit.

Jeez, as I type all this out, I’m convincing myself more and more to do this, but I won’t quite yet. I have a lot of additional topics to cover until I go this route.

Truth be told, I’m addicted to clicking “Publish”. It might be becoming a bad habit. It’s a hangover from the old SEO days (I never did get over the crank n’ bank content production strategy).

What’s the point here Jon? You’re boring me…

There’s a point.

I’m never 100% certain about what I should do. One week I’m geeked about investing K in content.

The next week I think I should slow new content and focus on making my sites better.

Some weeks I think I should write more content myself.

Then other weeks I tell myself I’ll only grow an online publishing business outsourcing everything.

This is a line of work full of known unknowns and the more difficult unknown unknowns.

Sound familiar?

If not, here’s the famous Donald Rumsfeld quote:

“Reports that say that something hasn’t happened are always interesting to me, because as we know, there are known knowns; there are things we know we know. We also know there are known unknowns; that is to say we know there are some things we do not know. But there are also unknown unknowns—the ones we don’t know we don’t know. And if one looks throughout the history of our country and other free countries, it is the latter category that tend to be the difficult ones.” – Donald Rumsfeld

If you’re second-guessing what to do, you’re in good company.

Welcome to the real world.

2 thoughts on “I had a 99% blogging failure rate – here’s what I did”

  1. Jon, am I missing something with the math? At only 3 visitor per page/day , and lets assume a 1000 page article, then we are looking at roughly 1000 visitors per year/article that costs $39.00 with the content provider. If I achieve a $10/cpm that means $10/year per article (1,000 visitors per year/article).
    I’d have to wait nearly 4 years to get a return on my article. Can you explain where my math is faulty?

    1. there is no fault in the math there..

      but for me, i find an article a success if it get 1000 pv per month. Its hard. and less than a quarter of my post get that kind of traffic, but, its already profitable..

      so for me, if one article get around 30pv perdays, that already excellent. Half of that is okay.. But like i say, more than half of my content is not anywhere near that, its a lost… but the succesfull content pay for all of it with many profit left.

      so, i think you should change how you target visitor for a content. Pick a reasonable one. I hope im clear enough, english isnt my first languange.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Scroll to Top